How Goes the ‘American Project’? I. Background


The main topic of this blog is U.S. fiscal and economic policies and especially, how, and to what extent, they are lacking. But every so often I take a broader perspective.
For example, the Swedish economist, Johan Norberg, has described in detail the remarkable human progress of the past 200 years, starting with the industrial revolution.  The British scholar, Matt Ridley, has given a cogent explanation of what brought about all of this progress.  Conclusion: human life, overall, has improved dramatically in the last 200 years and most likely will continue to improve well into the future.
How are things going in the U.S.?  Not so well, relatively speaking, according to the economist, Tyler Cowen.  He thinks that too many Americans are so self-satisfied with enjoying the fruits of prosperity that as a society we have become complacent about many hidden, but very serious, problems, such as debt, deteriorating life conditions for blue-collar workers, and a huge buildup of internet crime.  This complacency is likely to make America less dynamic in the future.

The eminent political scientist, Charles Murray, has weighed in on this issue with his tour-de-force tome, “Coming Apart: The State of White America 1960 – 2010.”   Mr. Murray describes a new kind of segregation which has developed in the U.S. based on socio-economic class, largely fueled by educational attainment and professional status.  The new Upper Class (20% of all Americans) are largely separated from the rest of society not only by the neighborhoods where they live and their professional employment but also because they are more likely to be married, hardworking and engaged in society.  The new Lower Class (30% of all Americans) has just the opposite characteristics of the Upper Class.
Mr. Murray argues that the four sources of deepest satisfaction in life are: family, vocation, community and faith and that these four main sources of satisfaction have become enfeebled for the Lower Class over the past 50 years.  But the Upper Class is also being hollowed out in other ways.
Conclusion. “Great nations eventually cease to be great,” observes Mr. Murray.  Is America doomed to moral deterioration and decay?  Stay tuned!

6 thoughts on “How Goes the ‘American Project’? I. Background

  1. I am glad you commented on Murray’s book. I think it poses a huge challenge for the country if we want to avoid being a culture in decline. Steve

    Sent from my iPad


  2. It is true that the fundamental social connections binding our citizens together have become increasingly fragile. We no longer can reasonably guarantee that almost all infants can expect to encounter especially nurturing parents during their first 2 years of life. The ‘social capital’ underpinning the Common Good of each family’s community is increasingly suffering from neglect. The only bright star is the level of volunteerism in many communities. As we increasing look to solve the health problems caused by the fragmentation of our family and neighborhood traditions, we will also realize that the problems with nation’s healthcare will not be solved without a strategy to improve our nation’s Population Health.

    • Good idea! Maybe organizing civic renewal around Community Health Care Centers is a good way to proceed. The mechanism for doing this is already a part of the ACA.

  3. Thank you for sharing these ideas presented by Charles Murray. It makes sense to me, is very disturbing, and motivates me to read his book.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s