Don’t Let Pessimism Overwhelm Idealism

“On what principle is it, that when we see nothing but improvement behind us, are we to expect nothing but deterioration before us?”
Thomas Babington Macauley, 1800 – 1859

In addition to my primary sources for this blog,  the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal, I also read a fair number of new books, often reviewed by these two newspapers.  I have just finished reading “Suicide of the West: how the rebirth of populism, nationalism and identity politics is destroying American democracy,” by Jonah Goldberg.


Mr. Goldberg’s main premises are:

  • We are living in an unnaturally prosperous time. Our prosperity is not merely material but political and philosophical.  We live in a miraculous time, by historical standards, where every human born is recognized by law and culture as a sovereign individual with inalienable rights.  This is not normal in humanity’s natural environment.
  • We stumbled into this miracle without intending to and we can stumble out of it.
  • Human nature not only exists but it is fundamentally unchanging.
  • If we do not account for, and channel human nature, it will overpower and corrupt the institutions that make prosperity possible.

Mr. Goldberg carefully documents the amazing human progress which has taken place since the eighteenth century, as have several other authors, see here, here, and here.

Here is how I evaluate Mr. Goldberg’s argument:

  • First of all, I agree with his description of our country’s many shortcomings: ingratitude for the miracle, history of slavery, the vast administrative state, the perniciousness of occupational licensing, bonfires of asininity at elite universities, the rising tide of protectionism, the family’s losing war against barbarism, Trumpian populism, government’s increasing centralization, etc., etc., etc.
  • But he is too hung up on the politics of the moment, and the failures of government. The “miracle” developed out of the fundamental economic principle of specialization and exchange and will be able to withstand less intrinsic human and societal imperfections.
  • There is a deep yearning for freedom and democracy around the world, see here  and here.  America doesn’t have to be perfect to serve as a beacon to others.  We just have to avoid being complacent.

Summary.  Jonah Goldberg’s “Suicide of the West” should be read and digested by everyone who values the American way of life and wants America to continue to prosper and lead the world into an even brighter future.

Follow me on Twitter 
Follow me on Facebook

2 thoughts on “Don’t Let Pessimism Overwhelm Idealism

  1. First, Machiavellian tactics increasingly dominate the world order for controlling the market-place arenas for its Knowledge, Resources, and Human Dignity. Progressively, the portion of our world’s citizens who live in a nation with constitutionally enforced Rights similar to our First Amendment (speech, press, religion, assembly, and petition) is decreasing. And finally, our nation suffers deeply from the decline of family life (viz municipal life, civil life, military life, judicial like, etc.). I refer to the importance of Family Life for each person’s gestational, early childhood, pre-adolescent safety, and adolescent mentoring for responsible adulthood. Family Traditions are stuck with ambiguity, such as the loss of Family Mealtimes and withdrawl from social networks. Our nation’s politics are grim, and we face the unknowns, largely unfocused, of global climate change. A nationally sanctioned strategy to redirect our nation’s focus on each person’s Famly, community by community, is the Appian Way to our nation’s future.

    Evidence of the current harm from all of this is represented by our nation’s worsening maternal mortality, infant mortality, childhood neglect/abuse, adolescent obesity/suicide, substance abuse/homicide, homelessness, mass shootings, mid-life depression/disability, senile dementia, and decreasing longevity at birth (now 4 years in a row).

    • These are all very serious problems which need to be addressed. Nevertheless if we as individuals are sufficiently determined we are usually able to avoid these problems by taking personal responsibility for our own welfare.
      All over the world there is a deep yearning for freedom and democracy. This is the best protection we have for preserving our own very attractive way of life.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s