The Folly of Building a Streetcar System in Omaha

 

The City of Omaha is now considering building a Streetcar System for an estimated cost of $156 million. Both of the two mayoral candidates have endorsed this proposal.

Here are the basic facts about the project:

  • It would run from TD Ameritrade Park in downtown Omaha to 42nd and Farnam Streets in midtown Omaha, a distance of about four miles. It would cost about $7.5 million per year to operate the line and would generate about $700,000 a year in annual revenue with a fare of $1.25 per ride. Adding a fee of $1.50 per ticket per College World Series event (at TD Ameritrade Park) would generate about $500,000 per year in additional income.

  • The financial assessment of the project by HDR suggests that the Federal Transit Administration could be asked for a grant of $78 million, or one-half of the total cost. The FTA is already contributing $15 million towards a $30 million Bus Rapid Transit system along Dodge Street approved by the City Council. The BRT involves 27 sleek, modern bus stop shelters along the route at a cost of $260,000 each.
  • The FTA has an annual budget of $19 billion. The Trump Administration is asking for a $2.4 billion cut in the FTA budget for 2018.  Congress has not yet taken any action on the Trump Budget proposal. But the FTA budget is clearly funding extravagant local projects around the country and is ripe for a major budget cut.

Conclusion. Omaha is simply not large enough, nor with a sufficiently dense population base, to support a downtown street car system aimed at the tourist trade. It could only be financed with massive federal support at a time when the federal government is rightly trying to cut back on unnecessary and wasteful spending. Don’t do it, Omaha!

6 thoughts on “The Folly of Building a Streetcar System in Omaha

  1. Omaha lost its extensive streetcar line @70 years ago. At that time, a large number of city streetcar systems throughout our nation were bought out by a company that made, and still makes, rubber tires. The streetcar companies were then all closed. We should just ask the University Nebraska Medical Center, Mutual of Omaha and the downtown business employers to pay for it. At least, we can be assured that it won’t end up like our poorly funded Postal System and Amtrak.

    P. S. The tire company (along with several co-conspirators) lost an anti-trust suit in 1949 but were only fined a pittance. Anti-trust suits seem to uniquely associated with tire companies.

  2. It does seem to be outrageously expensive. But if it gets people out and mingling with one another perhaps it will foster greater social awareness and communication among its citizens. Perhaps some sense of uniform neighborliness will result. Perhaps I am only daydreaming.
    Doug

    • The mayor has just said that it won’t be built without a vote of the people. I can’t imagine that it would be supported in a referendum. So perhaps it is already dead.

      • By the way has anyone done any kind of study on the use of the other forms of local travel in that area to bring people to the different locations such as the Old Market, Mid-Town Crossing, and etc., particularly along the river and the Bob Kerry bridge? I think we ought to spread the tourists around Omaha as much as we can.
        Doug

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s